About Tickled Pink and FAQs

Tickled Pink Cupcakery is Dayton's first gourmet cupcake bakery. Our cupcakes are made with the freshest ingredients: that means no additives or preservatives.  We pride ourselves in our moist cake, creamy frosting and unique flavors.  Where else in Dayton can you find a Banana Split cupcake?

Tickled Pink cupcakes are available for delivery for any occasion, including birthdays, weddings, showers, special events, office parties and more.  In addition to cupcakes, we also take orders for large special occasion cakes.  All of are treats can be customized to perfectly fit your needs.

Natalie Herr, owner and baker, started Tickled Pink in January 2009. She has always had a passion for baking, and loves creating new recipes. She is currently working on shipping methods to make Tickled Pink cupcakes available by mail across the country.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: If I order a dozen cupcakes, how many flavors can I get? 

A: The minimum order for any flavor is 1/2 dozen.  So if you're ordering 1 dozen cupcakes, you can choose up to 2 flavors. (This excludes large orders and variety packs.)

Q: How do I care for my Tickled Pink cupcakes?

A: Tickled Pink cupcakes are made fresh to order, and many are flash cooled before delivery.  Cupcakes with meringue topping or marshmallow frosting should always be kept at room temperature and are best eaten the day they are delivered.  Cupcakes with buttercream frosting can be kept at room temperature, but the frosting is best preserved when kept in the refrigerator.  We recommend removing the cupcakes from the fridge about 15-20 minutes before serving to allow them to come back to room temperature.  Cupcakes with buttercream frosting are also best eaten on the day of delivery, but tend to last longer than cupcakes with marshmallow or meringue.

Q: How do I unwrap my Tickled Pink cupcake?

A: Opening your Tickled Pink cupcake is simple.  Find the place where your cupcake liner has been snipped and tear away the liner.  If you're having trouble opening it, feel free to dig in with a spoon!

Q: Does Tickled Pink have a store front?

A: Tickled Pink does not have a store front at this time.  Tickled Pink cupcakes are currently available for delivery only.

Q: Can I order Tickled Pink cupcakes by mail?

A: We are currently working on strategies for sending our cupcakes, but they are not available by mail at this time.  This is a long process, and we'll continue to update you as we make progress.  

Q: Do you offer discounts for large orders and charities?

A: Yes, we do.  Discounts are given on a case-by-case basis.